The BMW 1 Series is one of the most accomplished sporty hatchbacks on sale.
However, if you don't fancy a car that turns every drive into a sprint race, there are lots of great options beyond the little BMW. We've chosen 10 of our favourite 1 Series competitors, ideal for singles, couples or small families.
You'll find many of these models available with thousands of pounds off their brand-new price when shopping Motorpoint's huge range of used cars.
Audi A3
Better than a 1 Series for: rear-seat space
With competition among the German 'big three' being so fierce, it's worth looking at the 1 Series' closest rivals, starting with the Audi A3. This modern-looking family hatchback starts out strong with a little more rear leg and foot room than the BMW, plus a sizeable cargo area if you avoid the plug-in-hybrid version. It's also a little more comfortable than the BMW, without the firmness inherent to all 1 Series models, although it's ever so slightly less sharp if you decide to attack a twisty back road.
Shop used Audi A3 cars for sale or read our Audi A3 review
Mercedes A-Class
Better than a 1 Series for: luxury
The other key competitor to the 1 Series is the Mercedes A-Class. This hatch takes comfort one stage further than both the Audi and the BMW, with a noticeably more compliant ride over rough surfaces. Again, the tradeoff is more body roll and less eagerness to turn into corners but, if you're just commuting around town, you might appreciate the Mercedes' softer approach. The interior isn't quite as sturdy as the BMW's but it looks a lot more glitzy, with lots of gloss black and metal-effect trim, plus plenty of leather upholstery.
Browse used Mercedes A-Class cars for sale or read our Mercedes A-Class review
BMW X1
Better than a 1 Series for: practicality
If the 1 Series' overall package appeals but its relatively small boot and rear seats mean it's too small for your needs, check out the BMW X1 SUV. Under the bodywork, it uses a lot of the same engines and parts as the 1 Series, giving it similarly composed handling but with a little extra softness to the ride that makes it a better family car choice. The cabin is much larger than its hatchback sibling with lots of space in the rear for adult passengers or bulky child seats, plus you get a far bigger boot that can handle pushchairs easily. There are plug-in hybrid and full EV versions of the X1 too, giving you more choice under the bonnet.
Search used BMW X1 cars
Toyota GR Yaris
Better than a 1 Series for: feeling like a racing driver on the way to the shops
Ok, so the BMW 1 Series M135i might be faster than the Toyota GR Yaris in a straight line, and the slightly milder 1 Series 128ti retains its practicality, but nothing on the road is quite like Toyota's pint-sized sledgehammer. You're unlikely to think it's cute and cuddly if you take in its hugely swollen bodywork and chopped stance, and that's true – the driving experience is visceral and involving. You can just imagine that the sight of queuing traffic makes the GR Yaris angrier than Ross Kemp, because it loves to devour open roads and flowing corners. For hot hatch excitement, you won't get better than the GR Yaris – but you might need to leave the kids at home and half the shopping in the supermarket car park.
Shop used Toyota GR Yaris cars for sale or read our Toyota GR Yaris review
Volkswagen Golf
Better than a 1 Series for: plug-in hybrid power
The Volkswagen Golf is still, in many ways, the hatchback against which other family contenders must be judged. It's positioned a little lower down in the group lineup than the 1 Series' most direct rival – the Audi A3 – which means your budget will usually buy a newer or higher spec Golf than a similarly priced 1 Series. As a result, you may be able to shop the Golf's plug-in-hybrid engines – something the 1 Series doesn't even offer as an option. When equipped with the 1.4 eHybrid or GTE engine, you can cover around 40 miles on electric power alone.
View used Volkswagen Golf cars for sale or read our Volkswagen Golf review
Mazda 3
Better than a 1 Series for: desirability
With the BMW badge already making a strong statement, it takes a very talented car to justify shopping elsewhere. Thankfully, the Mazda 3 scores highly across the board, whether you're checking out its dramatic, swoopy bodywork, or indulging in its plush, elegant cabin. Your BMW budget will buy a high-spec Mazda 3, which means lots of expensive feeling soft-touch materials in the cabin and leather upholstery on the seats. Take it down a twisty road and you'll also find the Mazda runs the 1 Series very close for driver appeal, too.
Take a look at used Mazda 3 cars
Mini Countryman
Better than a 1 Series for: cabin style
BMW won't tell you this but, underneath, the 1 Series uses a lot of the same parts and engines as cars from the Mini range. We don't think the Mini Hatchback is an obvious competitor because it's smaller than the BMW, but looking to the larger Countryman might make more sense. Despite being a very similar width and length as the BMW, the Countryman is far more practical, with lots of rear seat space and a big boot. But it's the cabin that wins the day for the Mini – it's much funkier and more exciting than the comparatively conservative 1 Series.
Find used Mini Countryman cars for sale
Ford Focus ST
Better than a 1 Series for: handling
The 1 Series is already a very sharp car, with a grippy, composed ride and an accurate, engaging front end. However, if you want great handling backed up by even more performance, check out the Ford Focus ST. This hot hatch achieves a similar trick to the BMW – feeling planted without being so firm you shake your fillings loose – but comes with a strong 280hp turbo petrol engine and a snappy manual gearbox to make the most of it.
Search used Ford Focus ST cars for sale
Lexus UX
Better than a 1 Series for: reliability
If you're buying your car for the long haul and not just for its PCP period, consider the Lexus UX. This is marketed as a compact SUV but looks and feels more like a big hatchback, with dimensions only slightly larger than the 1 Series. The cabin is luxurious but looks slightly more old-fashioned than the screen-laden BMW. However, the thing that keeps Lexus buyers flocking back to the brand is its unimpeachable reputation for reliability. Not only will the UX save you money on maintenance, but the smooth hybrid engine keeps fuel costs low, too.
Browse used Lexus UX cars for sale or read our Lexus UX review
Vauxhall Astra
Better than a 1 Series for: electric driving
You might not have realised that the familiar Vauxhall Astra now comes with the option of a fully electric version – it's very subtle, especially if you don't have the green flash on your number plates! The Astra is very efficient, and you can expect up to 250 miles from a full charge. Going EV can drastically reduce your fuel costs, especially if you can charge at home, while you can enjoy a smooth, quiet driving experience that's more refined than the 1 Series. We also think the latest Astra is a particularly handsome car with a modern interior. The best bit is that used electric Astras are currently exceptional value – you'll need to pay £5-10k less for a nearly new Astra than for a nearly new 1 Series.
Shop used Vauxhall Astra Electric cars for sale or read our Vauxhall Astra review
Find the right small family car for you
Check out Motorpoint's huge choice of great-value nearly new and used cars. For more options, take a look at our picks for the best compact family cars and our favourite small SUVs.
